Monday, 5 May 2014

Week 5: Crowdfunding

Crowdfunding. You probably heard this word here and there. It is quite a buzz word nowadays. But what is it really ? How does it work ? And should you engage or stay away ?

Let's start the topic by presenting its definition.
The practice of funding a project or venture by raising many small amounts of money from a large number of people, typically via the Internet. (c) Google
link to full picture


In simple words it means:
  • You have an idea, but you don't have funds to realize it
  • You describe your idea on one of crowdfunding sites 
  • Your idea is being viewed by thousands of people 
  • Some of them are willing to give you money upfront to see your ideas realized
  • You raise enough funds
  • You realize idea
  • All happy!
 But is  it really so simple ?
Well, like with any work, not quite. And here's why:

Your idea sucks!

    When we are talking about crowdfunding - we are talking about a lot of people (crowds, as the word itself suggests). And it is really hard to come up with an idea that will be liked by a lot of people and even harder to come up with such a good idea, that people will be ready to pay you money for. Even if you come up with such a brilliant idea you need to describe it in a way people would like it. Lots of crowdfunding campaigns failed because creators were not able to describe it in the way people would understand it and like it.

    Prove me you can realize your idea!

    Not only the idea should be good for it to be successfully crowdfunded, but your future customer needs to be able to believe that you are capable of realizing this idea. You will need to prove - you're the right man (group) for the job.  If you're are a group of professional football players who want to build an airspace shuttle - you may have problems crowdfunding your campaign.

    I gave you money so where is my product? 

    When you ask for money for a product upfront you need to inform you customer quite precisely when he will receive a product he's paid for. When you create a new product, delays are almost unavoidable and therefore you need to plan your campaign and communication with customers very carefully to meet their expectations.

    Can't really see what I am buying...

    Probably the biggest problem: a customer is paying for a promise, for a nice description, for a promising team, for an early prototype... for all that, but not the final product, which means there is always a chance that a customer will not be satisfied with what he has paid for.


    Here are a few more facts about crowdfunding:

    Link to full picture

    Examples of very successful crowdfunding campaigns:

    Most popular crowdfunding sites: 

    Another way to look at crowdfunding:

    There is a recent trend to use crowdfunding: for your idea validation rather than fund raising. In essence it is quite easy and logical: we all have ideas, but how can we know if our idea is interesting for anyone except ourselves ? How can we know if spending our time, work and money to realize this idea will pay off ? Will anybody buy it ? As you can see those questions could be addressed by a crowdfunding campaign. So it becomes a tool to reduce a risk and a platform to receive valuable customer feedback.

    Small personal example:

    There is a guy, a foreigner who lives in London. He's a successful marketeer and he worked for one of the biggest London's marketing agencies. In his free time, he likes to take his friends for short walking tours around London. He's showing and telling stories to them about London's interesting places: like a collection of street art situated in different parts of the city, old, unused metro stations, hidden buildings, monuments and other less known attractions of the "capital of the Great Britain".  He  thought what if this hobby could become a real business ? But as any responsible person, who has a wife and a young child, he had his doubts. He was asking himself those questions: How many people might be interested in those walks ? How much can I charge for it ? Will it be enough to make a living ? ... and many, many more. What he really needed was validation of his idea. And so he went to a crowdfunding site and started a campaign to raise 5000 pounds in 40 days. His statement was: if I am able to meet this campaign goal - I will quit my current job and start a new business. Getting money was not his main target, he was rather looking for feedback from potential customers with the aim to identify if there are any "customers", 'Will they be ready to pay and what their expectations are going to be?'. He prepared to write one blog post a day about London to convince potential backers that he indeed knows this stuff. Within 2 and a half days his campaign  was complete, 5000 pounds were gathered and a happy new businessman went to submit resignation papers. This small story shows that crowdfunding actually works ! Works not only for companies with a complicated product who needs money to finish it, but it also works for individuals who wants to find other individuals ready to support an idea with their money and feedback.

    Few questions to trigger discussion:

    • What is your experience with crowdfunding ? Have you ever participated in a crowdfunding campaign as a contributor or a receiver ? 
    • Do you think crowdfunding has already become an alternative to classic ways of funding an initiative, like: loans, angels and venture investments, IPOs and so on ? Or it may become in future ? 
    • Do you have an idea that you always wanted to validate but didn't know how ? Would you consider doing it through a crowdfunding campaign ?

    27 comments:

    1. This comment has been removed by the author.

      ReplyDelete
    2. To be honest, I don't know much about crowdfunding, as I have never had the need to exploit the topic. I don't know any person who has taken part in such an initiative either. However, I believe that any kind of activity taken in order to make one's dreams come true, is good and should be supported. Though, I can see a possible danger in that some people may try crowdfunding in order to raise money in a quick way, without much effort. That is why, I think, we should be very careful while supporting crowdfunders financially.

      ReplyDelete
      Replies
      1. Indeed, there were a couple of cases when money was raised and product never created. Most of crowdfunding platforms have built-in mechanics of returning money to backers if goals of a campaign haven't been reached.
        Do you think such way of raising funds should be monitored by the government ?

        Delete
      2. But it can also work the other side.
        For example, someone who has the money can use someone else's idea for their own purposes.
        Is such cases also took place?

        Delete
      3. I haven't heard about cases of idea stealing on crowdfunding platforms, but I would assume such thing could happen.
        In the same time, I believe, it does not make a lot of difference. Bare idea is only a relatively small part of possible product success. Execution matters much more. You could give one idea to two different persons and end up with two different products, one could be successful while the other will not.

        Delete
    3. In my opinion the goverment monitoring can demage the idea. But probably, every person who wants to get money from other people should first buy some kind of insurance? So if the idea will not be realizmem, then the insurance company will pay the money back to the people who invested in it?

      ReplyDelete
      Replies
      1. It might work similar to when you buy a product in the shop - if this product does not work or do not meet your expectations you can return it.

        Delete
      2. Daniel
        Very good idea that it functioned as the purchase of the product in store.
        But is it really such a function?

        Delete
      3. What if you cannot find the peson? As I understand it is all made via internet there is almost no real connection?

        Delete
    4. Currently there are different mechanics in place:
      First of all, business reputation. If you as a creator does not fulfill expectations of you backers - there is almost no chance they are going to trust you again, moreover, they probably tell about you to their friends and your chances to start a new project will be very low.

      In addition to that some crowdfunding platforms also provides a way for legal prosecution. Like the following example from Kickstarter:

      Is a creator legally obligated to fulfill the promises of their project?

      Yes. Kickstarter's Terms of Use require creators to fulfill all rewards of their project or refund any backer whose reward they do not or cannot fulfill. (This is what creators see before they launch.) This information can serve as a basis for legal recourse if a creator doesn't fulfill their promises. We hope that backers will consider using this provision only in cases where they feel that a creator has not made a good faith effort to complete the project and fulfill.

      ReplyDelete
    5. I have to admit I have no idea what crowfounding is. Or I should say - I had no idea. Thank you for your presentation, it was good point to meet this phenomenom. But I can't say anything in this field since I'm not even an enterpreneur and I don't plan to be :)

      ReplyDelete
    6. I do not have any experience in crowdfunding and I have never taken part in it.
      I think that this is a very cool idea for people who have interesting business ideas but do not have the capital, and vice versa.
      I think that crowdfunding has a future but only when the both parties will be more protected.
      At the moment I do not have any idea that I could carry out using crowdfunding.

      ReplyDelete
    7. As I’m really into game and gadgets industry I read about crowdfunding daily (I’m even crowdfunding new project: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/armikrog/armikrog). I loved “The Neverhood” (point-and-click game from my childhood), so I seceded to invest in the new project of its creators. Not only will I get a new game, but I will receive extra content.

      You wrote about supporting idea, I would like to extend this by writing about “Steam greenlight” (http://steamcommunity.com/greenlight). Greenlight can be explained as a queue for games, that can’t be published for different reasons. Players decide which game will have an opportunity, by voting on the games they would like to purchase. (You do not need to pay for that or declare anything).

      There is also another aspect of crowdfunding - by your financial support, you can decide which project will be developed. Not so long ago on http://kolekti.pl/you were able to decide which audiobook will be recorded.

      ReplyDelete
      Replies
      1. Thank you for sharing you experience Jakub.
        It's great to see some people giving crowdfunding a chance and that it works for them.

        I like the idea of Steam Greenlight - I think it gives young developers a great chance to announce themselves.

        And it's extremely interesting to see some polish examples of crowdfunding.

        tnx,

        Delete
    8. Personally, I am convinced of the success of this type of business solutions in today's world, where not everyone has a chance to help from the state. Subsidy is also not easy to obtain. I didn’t have direct contact with this phenomenon, but I've heard of one case of such an action in Poland. Students from the Technical University of Wroclaw passed, as one of the top ten teams, to the final "Space is More" organized by NASA. Spectacular success - in the competition participated teams from all over the world. They were invited to the United States - and the problem occurred. They had no money to travel. When every possible source of funding failed, students have turned for help to the Internet users. Thanks to that they managed to collect 30,000 zł for the trip. So this is also an excellent example of the effectiveness of such ideas.
      If you want read more about students:
      http://tvnmeteo.tvn24.pl/informacje-pogoda/ciekawostki,49/docenila-ich-nasa-w-polsce-maja-problem-na-wyjazd-do-usa-brakuje-im-pieniedzy,119578,1,0.html

      ReplyDelete
      Replies
      1. great example ! tnx for sharing !
        and shame that neither state, no university was able to support them....

        Delete
    9. Unfortunatelly, I love crowdfounding (to be precise I love the funding part of it). I can spend a whole day searching through Kickstarter's projects. And I spend much too much money on them.
      The only thing I do not like is waiting for the delayed deliveries. Last June or July I supported a yoga mat project. This mat was supposed to be delivered till September - I received it two months ago. And the problem wasn't really that it was delayed - it can happen. What I didn't like was a lack of information from the producer - I didn't know why it is delayed, when will it be delivered, or even if it will be delivered.
      So a good advice for all who would like to start a crowdfunding project - do not ignore your supporters, even if the things start to go wrong. Or even especially then.

      ReplyDelete
    10. Actually, I crowdfunded some polish project. In my opinion this is great idea, because men who set some projects up feel that he/she is part of it.
      I recommend following sites:
      http://wspieramkulture.pl
      http://polakpotrafi.pl

      I also recommend this ted talk: http://www.ted.com/talks/amanda_palmer_the_art_of_asking

      ReplyDelete
    11. I’ve seen lot’s of croudfounding actions, but only few very successful form Poland... I’ve seen charity croudfounding pages allowing you to fund money for a needy person.
      In any case, it’s one more of the many examples showing us limitless possibilities of internet and communication channels it offers.
      Haven’t participated in any such action yet, maybe because I’m not tracking those pages so often – you need to see the idea first to be fascinated and the donate some money... And although some of the ideas may be interesting there’s the issue you mentioned “What I’m actually buying?”. Sometimes it just this “promise” and in other cases it’s only a “supporting” t-shirt or cup ;) or maybe a dinner with action founders... But it’s great we have this opportunity and can use it whenever needed.

      ReplyDelete
    12. Crowdfounding is a great concept, I love the variety of "products" you can support, from technology to music (f.e. bands trying to release an album without the necessity of joining a label which usually leaves the artist with just a fer percent of income).

      ReplyDelete
    13. I found crowdfunding platforms as a good mean to look for money for projects lead by eccentric individualists which couldn't stand often having their hands tied in big companies. Kickstarter hosted many former gaming directors (but not only them), bolsterous and/or unruly, but extremely talented, dedicated and focused on delivering good product - and with a huge worldwide following (e.g. Chris Roberts, Brian Fargo, Tim Schaefer)

      ReplyDelete
    14. I've never participated in crowdfunding. I'm interested in all kind of IT areas and I found crowdfunding really astonishing. In some markets crowdfunding changed completely rules of the game. Literally...game. In computer games market and in overall media/RTV market there was a revolution. At the beginning there was a wave of excitement because some awesome projects were founded. Those ideas were rejected by market before crowdfunding. It showed people that sentence “The demand creates the supply” is a piece of crap in mass market. Companies were not producing what people really want as long as customers will be buying stuff that is not completely sufficient for their needs. In computer games it was a blast for big companies and they started communicating with customers faster than a bullet.
      How is it now? As always....market conformed to the idea and they started to sell alpha and beta version of their software. Officialy they want to know the customer feedback before the premiere, but if you can buy something a year before the premiere...is it really a premiere? That's not the win-win situation. People buy that alpha crap, and company has free testers and money earlier...

      ...and ...oh. What was the questions? Ah yes.

      “Do you think crowdfunding has already become an alternative to classic ways of funding an initiative, like: loans, angels and venture investments, IPOs and so on ? Or it may become in future ?  “
      Yes.
      “Do you have an idea that you always wanted to validate but didn't know how ? Would you consider doing it through a crowdfunding campaign ? “

      Yes.

      ReplyDelete
    15. I have heard some time ago about this initiative, and from day one I'm skeptical to it. If someone is asking me to pay upfront for some kind of service I have a little yellow light in the back of my head. This is not a usual situation and to do what that person asks I would need to have some faith in that person. I would need to believe that he is not going to deceive me.
      I think that in Poland that kind of initiative will not be a big and successful, but I hope to be wrong. I can even say that I someone would convince me to that initiative I will start my first business there. I mean it!

      ReplyDelete
    16. First of all it's a not controlled area of the market and it is going to grow, we all know that, but once it will grow too much, the government will cut it, because basically, it's not a healthy solution for the market. I would rather compare this kind of a solution to the grants from EU for the farmers. Also startups are not a good idea when it's not controlled and it can be practiced by a non professionals. It basicaly causes the budget whole, which means you take money from people and you can do whatever you want to with this money and this is a very bad situation, because half of this money you can really spend on the project and the rest will be your income. Then you will spend the income on goods not investing it. This is how the market collapse. The money must flow, once injected to the business it must flow :P and many of the startup projects are not even close to be successful but they still try lolz , this is sad. I hope i am one wrong pessimist :-)

      ReplyDelete
    17. This comment has been removed by the author.

      ReplyDelete
    18. Well, someone had the same idea like me :) I heard about cat cafes in Japan and it has really gotten me thinking about this business in Poland. I wondered, will it be catchy for us, Europeans? I'm positively suprised, that this is it. I have never heard about crowdfunding. I think, it can teach us dynamic action in civil society.

      ReplyDelete
    19. Crowdfunding is a very fine concept, unfortunately in Poland it’s not well develop yet. My friend who is an artist used crowdfunding in order to produce the music clip which then got about 500 000 views on YouTube. He got popular in the internet which gave him an opportunity to get funding for another clip, which he made use of.
      I’ve always wanted to make a real wing house in Poland, but unfortunately crowdfunding market in Poland is not big enough to raise this amount of money.

      ReplyDelete